Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Menu

Please check our online store or come by as some of our menu items may change... and we often have seasonal and holiday specific treats!

Pies

Slice of Pie

$5

Fruit Pies

  • Apple Pie

    with butter crust or butter *pecan* crumb topping

    $26

  • Blackberry Pie

    with butter crust or butter *pecan* crumb topping

    $27

  • Blueberry Pie

    with butter crust or butter *pecan* crumb topping

    $27

  • Cherry Pie

    with butter crust or butter *pecan* crumb topping

    $27

  • Cranberry Apple Pie

    with butter crust or butter *pecan* crumb topping

    $27

  • Pumpkin Pie

    $26

  • Raspberry Pie

    with butter crust or butter *pecan* crumb topping

    $27

  • Rhubarb Pie

    with butter crust or butter *pecan* crumb topping

    $26

  • Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

    with butter crust or butter *pecan* crumb topping

    $27

  • Sweet Potato

    $26

  • Seasonal Fresh Berry Pies

    Blackberry Dream or Strawberry Deluxe

    $40

Mincemeat Pie

  • Whole Pie

    $40

  • Slice

    $8.50

Nut & Chess Pies

  • Almond Chess Pie

    $26

  • Chocolate Coconut Chess Pie

    $26

  • Lemon Chess Pie

    $26

  • Bourbon Walnut Pie

    $26

  • Chocolate Pecan Pie

    $26

  • Coconut Custard Pie

    $25.50

  • Peanut Butter Pie

    $27

  • Pecan Pie

    $26

Meringue Pies

  • Lemon Meringue Pie

    $25.50

  • Chocolate Meringue Pie

    $25.50

  • Coconut Meringue Pie

    $25.50

  • Key Lime Meringue Pie

    $25.50

Cream Pies

  • Chocolate Cream Pie

    $26

  • Coconut Cream Pie

    $26

  • Banana Cream Pie

    $26

  • Boston Crème Cream Pie

    $26

Specialty Baked Goods

  • Mini Pineapple Upsidedown Cake

    $5

  • Whoopie Pies

    $3

  • Brownie

    Chocolate-covered (contains pecans)

    $3.50

  • Buckeye

    $2.25

  • Lemon Bar

    $3.50

  • Cinnamon Roll

    Single $5.50

    Box of 4 $20

    Half dozen $30

  • Molasses Delight

    $4.50

  • Plum Corn Muffins

    $1.50

Cakes

  • Cheesecake

    Whole pie $15

  • Truffle Cake

    (Contains Bourbon)

    Whole pie $15

Cookies

Cookies

  • Box of Sugar Cookies

    Dozen- all iced $40

    Dozen- half iced half sugar $34

    Dozen- All Sprinkle $28

    Half dozen- all iced $20

    Half dozen- 3 iced 3 sprinkle $17

    Half Dozen- All Sprinkle $14

Classic Cookies

  • Chocolate Chip

    $1

  • Oatmeal Raisin

    $1

  • Oatmeal Chocolate Chip

    $1

Sugar Cookies

  • Sprinkle

    $2.25

  • Iced

    $3.25

  • Custom

    Variable

  • Dipped

    $2.25

Shortbread

  • Ginger

    $1.75

  • Dark Chocolate Chunk

    $1.75

  • Lemon Rosemary

    $1.75

  • Any 3

    $5

Specialty Cookies

  • Linzer

    $4

    Box of 6 $24

  • Mexican Wedding Cookies

    $1

    Mexican Wedding Cookies (3) $2.75

  • Million Dollar Cookie (pecans)

    $4

  • Molasses

    $1

  • Monster Cookie (peanut butter)

    $4

  • Peanut Butter Cookies

    Reese's PB Cup

    $1.75

  • Peanut Butter Cookies

    $1.75

    gluten free

  • Sugar Scrap Cookies

    $5

  • Black & Whites

    $3.50

Seasonal Cookies

  • Thumbprint Cookies

    Apricot, plum, or raspberry

    $1.50

Breads

Small Sweet Loaves

  • Apple Nut

    $6

  • Banana

    $6

  • Banana Chocolate Chip

    $6

  • Banana Nut

    $6

  • Gingerbread (seasonal)

    $6.50

  • Eggnog (seasonal)

    $6.50

  • Pumpkin (seasonal)

    $6

  • Zesty Plum and Cream Cheese

    $6.50

Mom's Breads

  • Sunflower Crunch Loaf

    $6

  • Buttermilk

    $6

Speacialty Breads

  • Pulla

    $10

  • Challah

    $10

  • Irish Soda

    $10

Ice Cream

Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches

We carry a variety of Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches; they offer seasonal options, so availability listed here may be different from what you find in store!

  • Classic

    $5

  • Cookie Monster

    $5

  • Chocolate Blackout

    $5

  • Strawberry Shortcake

    $5

  • Chocolate French Roast

    $5

  • Banana Pudding

    $5

  • Key Lime

    $5

  • Miso Churro

    $5

  • Black Forest Cherry

    $5

  • Mango Lemonade

    $5

  • Rainbow Cookie Dough

    $5

  • Red Velvet Cheesecake

    $5

  • Apple Cider

    $5

  • White Chocolate Truffle

    $5

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream Pints

  • Vanilla Bean

    $7.50

  • Pistachio

    $7.50

  • Honeycomb

    $7.50

  • Brooklyn Brown Sugar Chunk

    $7.50

  • Marionberry Cheesecake

    $7.50

  • Rasberry Layer Cake

    $7.50

  • Buttermilk Berry Cornbread

    $7.50

  • Cookies & Cream

    $7.50

  • Peanut Butter Brownie Honeycomb

    $7.50

  • Black Cherry Chip

    $7.50

  • Vegan Brown Sugar

    $7.50

  • Earl Grey

    $7.50

  • Mint Chip

    $7.50

  • Strawberry

    $7.50

  • Peppermint Stick

    $7.50

  • Praline Butter Cake

    $7.50

  • Hazelnut Fudge Cookie

    $7.50

Hot Coffee & Tea

  • Intelligentsia Coffee - Drip Coffee by the Cup

    12oz $2.50

    16oz $3

    20oz $3.50

  • Black Cat Espresso - Whole Bean

    $16.50 per 12oz bag

  • House Blend - Whole Bean

    $16 per 12oz

  • Decaf House - Whole Bean

    $17

  • Hugo Tea

    Enjoy a variety of Hugo's "Direct & Masterful" tea selections.

    Small $2

    Medium $2.50

    Large $3

Sprecher Sodas

  • Cherry

    $3

  • Grape

    $3

  • Orange Dream

    $3

  • Cream

    $3

  • Root Beer

    $3

Savory

Egg Bites

  • Spinach

    $2.50

  • Lorraine (Bacon Swiss)

    $2.50

  • Corn And Peppers

    $2.50

Quiche

  • Spinach and Swiss

    $22.50

  • Lorraine (Bacon Swiss)

    $22.50

  • Corn, Peppers, Asiago, and Sage

    $22.50

  • Broccoli Cheddar

    $22.50

  • Chicken Pasta Salad

    Regular $7

  • Chicken Salad

    Regular $7

Email Signup

Please check errors in the form above
Thank you for signing up for email updates!
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.